Draft Intelligence
GM Performance
Evaluating every NFL GM's draft track record from 2018 to 2025 using Draft Impact Score (DIS) and Value Over Tier Average (VOTA). 2059 picks analyzed across 32 front offices.
DIS
Draft Impact Score. Combines draft-relative AV percentile with z-score normalization. Measures raw production relative to draft class.
VOTA
Value Over Tier Average. How much better (or worse) a pick performs vs the average pick in its draft tier (Top 10, Rd 1, Day 2, etc).
Hit Rate
Percentage of picks graded Grand Slam or Steal. The best GMs consistently find above-expectation value across all rounds.
1
BUF
Brandon Beane
Buffalo Bills · 2017–present · 64 picks
+0.060
VOTA
2
TB
Jason Licht
Tampa Bay Buccaneers · 2018–present · 59 picks
+0.057
VOTA
3
WAS
Adam Peters
Washington Commanders · 2024–present · 14 picks
+0.055
VOTA
4
HOU
Nick Caserio
Houston Texans · 2021–present · 41 picks
+0.042
VOTA
5
IND
Chris Ballard
Indianapolis Colts · 2017–present · 74 picks
+0.036
VOTA
6
LAC
Joe Hortiz
Los Angeles Chargers · 2024–present · 18 picks
+0.032
VOTA
7
TEN
Mike Borgonzi
Tennessee Titans · 2025–present · 9 picks
+0.030
VOTA
8
KC
Brett Veach
Kansas City Chiefs · 2017–present · 55 picks
+0.026
VOTA
9
PIT
Omar Khan
Pittsburgh Steelers · 2022–present · 28 picks
+0.026
VOTA
10
LA
Les Snead
Los Angeles Rams · 2018–present · 75 picks
+0.021
VOTA
11
NYG
Joe Schoen
New York Giants · 2022–present · 31 picks
+0.019
VOTA
12
SF
John Lynch
San Francisco 49ers · 2017–present · 67 picks
+0.019
VOTA
13
DEN
George Paton
Denver Broncos · 2021–present · 38 picks
+0.017
VOTA
14
CHI
Ryan Poles
Chicago Bears · 2022–present · 34 picks
+0.016
VOTA
15
DET
Brad Holmes
Detroit Lions · 2021–present · 36 picks
+0.016
VOTA
16
PHI
Howie Roseman
Philadelphia Eagles · 2018–present · 60 picks
+0.016
VOTA
17
NYJ
Darren Mougey
New York Jets · 2025–present · 7 picks
+0.015
VOTA
18
GB
Brian Gutekunst
Green Bay Packers · 2018–present · 80 picks
+0.013
VOTA
19
CIN
Duke Tobin
Cincinnati Bengals · 2018–present · 68 picks
+0.010
VOTA
20
DAL
Jerry Jones
Dallas Cowboys · 2018–present · 69 picks
+0.009
VOTA
21
NE
Eliot Wolf
New England Patriots · 2024–present · 19 picks
+0.001
VOTA
22
SEA
John Schneider
Seattle Seahawks · 2018–present · 69 picks
+0.001
VOTA
23
BAL
Eric DeCosta
Baltimore Ravens · 2019–present · 63 picks
-0.003
VOTA
24
NO
Mickey Loomis
New Orleans Saints · 2018–present · 50 picks
-0.006
VOTA
25
CAR
Dan Morgan
Carolina Panthers · 2024–present · 15 picks
-0.021
VOTA
26
JAX
James Gladstone
Jacksonville Jaguars · 2025–present · 9 picks
-0.025
VOTA
27
CLE
Andrew Berry
Cleveland Browns · 2020–present · 44 picks
-0.026
VOTA
28
LV
John Spytek
Las Vegas Raiders · 2025–present · 11 picks
-0.054
VOTA
29
ARI
Monti Ossenfort
Arizona Cardinals · 2023–present · 28 picks
-0.078
VOTA
30
ATL
Ian CunninghamNew (2026)
Atlanta Falcons · 2026–present · 0 picks
—
VOTA
31
MIA
Jon-Eric SullivanNew (2026)
Miami Dolphins · 2026–present · 0 picks
—
VOTA
32
MIN
Rob BrzezinskiNew (2026)
Minnesota Vikings · 2026–present · 0 picks
—
VOTA